I recently came across a video that touted the advantages of riding bareback. The main claim was that bareback riding allowed for a more refined communication between a horse and the rider’s seat. I’ve heard this many times in the past. Some people believe that if we want closer communication with our horse, we should ride bareback.
I have some disagreement with this idea for a few reasons.
Firstly, it assumes that the rider has excellent balance and feel when riding without a saddle. This is often not true. Not everybody can sit on a horse bareback as if they were part of the horse. Many tense their back or grip with their legs or clench their seat, and any combination of those. So if a saddle helps those riders be softer and better balanced, they should ride in a saddle with a suitable seat and balance.
But the most important reason I believe riding bareback should be kept to a minimum is for the horse.
Occasionally riding bareback is fine (provided the horse is sound). But I believe regular or prolonged bareback riding is bad for a horse's health and comfort over time.
For one, the seat bones of a human cause pressure points on the muscles of the horse's back. However, a well-fitting saddle, with a solid tree, distributes the rider’s weight more evenly along the back, minimising the damage that pressure “hotspots” can cause on the muscles of the back.
Furthermore, bareback riding does not allow a gullet for the rider’s seat to clear the spine. This causes the spine to endure some degree of weight bearing, which it was never designed to do. This can lead to problems like a hollow back and (I suspect) spinal issues.
I believe riding in a well-fitted saddle with a tree is a better alternative than riding bareback, both for the horse and the rider. In response to the claim in the video that bareback provides better communication between rider and horse, I feel that if you can't do a good job of feeling and communicating with a horse when riding with a well-fitting saddle, then you can't do it when riding bareback.
